Let’s face it, banger leagues are just more fun.
The difficulty level is ratcheted up because there are more categories and players to consider, but it’s also totally upended how we evaluate them as fantasy assets. In leagues that emphasize scoring, there is no debate Connor McDavid should go first. Zero. He’s always the best bet to score the most points and the potential winning margin is in the double-digits.
But it’s no longer a tap-in decision if you consider categories such as hits and faceoff wins. Suddenly, checking-line players and defensive defensemen have some value, and the pure scoring talents such as Johnny Gaudreau end up falling down the lists.
No, I’m not setting you up for some silly hot take that someone else is ranked above McDavid. Scoring is still the hardest thing to do, making it a premium because a goal is much harder to obtain than a hit or a blocked shot.
Below are the Top 200 players for leagues that take into consideration goals (G), assists (A), plus-minus (+/-), penalty minutes (PIM), power-play points (PPP), shots (S), blocks (BkS), hits and faceoffs won (FOW). Positions are based on Yahoo’s website and multiple-position eligibility can be a bonus, especially for centers with right or left wing eligibility.
The methodology is simple: I cover my eyes and throw darts at a board.
Kidding. Goals and assists are still worth the most. Each player has a value and rank for scoring categories (G, A, +/-, PPP, S) and banger categories (PIM, Bks, Hits, FOW), which are then blended and adjusted. The players are not ranked strictly by any one statistical measure. Stat projections for individual players can be found in the awesome Pool Guide.
Note there are no goalies on this list. They will be placed on a different list and ranked numerically and in tiers, but only for the pre-season. The categories for players and goalies are completely different and their overall fantasy value will depend on your league settings. Other than knowing Igor Shesterkin and Andrei Vasilevskiy are the only two goalies worth drafting in the first round in most formats, the rest tend to get drafted in clusters, either by round or team. It’s better to wait and find out how some of the goaltending timeshares will shake out before ranking them on a combined list.
Once the season begins, the list will be updated on a regular basis and include both players and goalies with more write-ups.
Good luck!
1. Connor McDavid, C, Oilers
Any time McDavid doesn’t go first overall in any league, it should be controversial. But that’s the inherent fun with banger leagues, because if you consider shots and faceoff wins, McDavid is not a consensus first overall pick. However, since points are weighted the most heavily, the Art Ross champion two years in a row is No. 1 by default.
2. Auston Matthews, C, Maple Leafs
The league’s lone 60-goal scorer is an annual Rocket Richard favourite and his faceoff abilities have really improved in a short period of time. He shoots and scores more than anyone else.
3. Leon Draisaitl, C/LW, Oilers
There’s major added value with LW eligibility and also a chance Draisaitl ends up being No. 1 on this list since he wins more faceoffs than both McDavid and Matthews. Where Draisaitl falls slightly behind is in point production and shot volume.
4. Nathan MacKinnon, C, Avalanche
Bag secured, but poor faceoff ability could push MacKinnon further down the list. MacKinnon barely won 50 percent of his faceoffs in his best season and has been very poor in the dot for an elite scoring center.
5. Nikita Kucherov, RW, Lightning
No other winger scores at the pace Kucherov does and he will challenge McDavid for the scoring title, which glosses over his mediocre banger category contributions. Among the top 50 on this list, Kucherov’s scoring rank was top-five and his banger rank bottom-five, but his scoring was so off-the-charts good he deserves to stay up here.
6. Aleksander Barkov, C, Panthers
Barkov’s offense grades out very high with a 107-point pace last season and he’s one of the league’s best in faceoffs. It’s a deep position but Barkov represents the last of the elite young centers.
7. Roman Josi, D, Predators
Josi is one of two defensemen worth taking in the first round and his body of work was incredible last season with 90-plus points and excellent peripherals, including almost 300 shots. The Smashville workhorse should have a similarly productive season.
8. Alex Ovechkin, LW, Capitals
Declining penalty minutes and hits means Ovechkin’s value in banger leagues takes a slight dip, but considering he was the only other player to score at least 50 goals with at least 300 shots – the other being Matthews – he’s still a top left winger.
9. Sidney Crosby, C, Penguins
Crosby’s improved defense has not come at the cost of his offense. Crosby ranked 18th in P/GP (1.22) and 10th in total faceoff wins (760), and only one other center – Draisaitl: 1.38 P/GP, 887 FOW – beat him in both categories.
10. Cale Makar, D, Avalanche
Makar’s point-per-game production already makes him a top-tier player, but he stands out even more for being a defenseman. His seemingly unlimited ceiling is the main reason why he would be drafted before Josi, who had a slightly higher banger rating.
11. Steven Stamkos, C/LW, Lightning
The LW eligibility should be huge if Stamkos plays center full-time. He’s one of four players to have scored at least 70 power-play goals over the past five seasons and also ranks 11th in P/GP.
12. Jonathan Huberdeau, LW, Flames
How does Huberdeau mesh with his new team? Other than being an elite scorer at a fairly thin position, his fantasy value in banger leagues is debatable because he offers little else, though note his 99 hits last season were slightly more than your typical first-line scorer.
13. Gabriel Landeskog, C/LW, Avalanche
The issue with Landeskog is health; he’s missed 49 games over the past three seasons compared to only 43 in the eight prior seasons. Otherwise, Landeskog is a Banger League Beast™, now even offering some faceoff wins and better-than-average scoring.
14. J.T. Miller, C/LW, Canucks
The key question is if Miller’s 99-point season was a fluke because that’s the biggest reason for him to be ranked so high. If his scoring drops, his main value will be winning a lot of faceoffs from your LW slot.
15. Brady Tkachuk, LW, Senators
Tkachuk is a unicorn and could be ranked in the top five in roto leagues. Note only one other player (David Backes) in the cap era has managed to register at least 20 goals, 100 PIM, 200 shots and 200 hits in a single season, and both of them have now done it at least twice.
16. Kirill Kaprizov, LW, Wild
Kaprizov’s one of a handful of players who can score over 100 points and his usage should be through the roof on a thin Wild offense. He doesn’t offer up a ton of banger stats, but he has 50-goal, 300-shots potential.
17. Mikko Rantanen, C/RW, Avalanche
Scoring helps push Rantanen up the rankings but he doesn’t offer up a ton of peripherals, and when the Avs are healthy, he’s usually playing right wing. Eligibility at C won’t mean much if he’s not winning faceoffs and fantasy managers shouldn’t be playing him in that slot, either.
18. Matthew Tkachuk, RW, Panthers
Last season, Tkachuk with Elias Lindholm and Johnny Gaudreau graded out as arguably the league’s best line, so a regression in scoring is very possible playing on a new team. With the amount of trouble he causes on the ice, you’d think Tkachuk would be a fantasy unicorn like brother Brady, but he’s definitely a tier below with fewer PIM and hits.
19. Patrice Bergeron, C, Bruins
Bergeron’s high-scoring ranking was a big surprise. He scores close to a point-per-game pace, registered close to 300 shots last season and also paced the league with 991 faceoff wins. The margin between Bergeron’s faceoff wins and second-place Ryan O’Reilly (91) is close to the margin between O’Reilly and seventh-place John Tavares (87), which shows just far ahead Bergeron was.
20. Timo Meier, LW/RW, Sharks
Dig deeper and there’s a strong case for Meier to be here. He’s got 40-goal potential, finished third in the league with 326 shots last season and also low-key added 162 hits, which ranks third among the top 20 on this list behind J.T. Miller and Brady Tkachuk.
Here’s a look at the full 200-player list:
- Connor McDavid, C, Oilers
- Auston Matthews, C, Maple Leafs
- Leon Draisaitl, C/LW, Oilers
- Nathan MacKinnon, C, Avalanche
- Nikita Kucherov, RW, Lightning
- Aleksander Barkov, C, Panthers
- Roman Josi, D, Predators
- Alex Ovechkin, LW, Capitals
- Sidney Crosby, C, Penguins
- Cale Makar, D, Avalanche
- Steven Stamkos, C/LW, Lightning
- Jonathan Huberdeau, LW, Flames
- Gabriel Landeskog, C/LW, Avalanche
- J.T. Miller, C/LW, Canucks
- Brady Tkachuk, LW, Senators
- Kirill Kaprizov, LW, Wild
- Mikko Rantanen, C/RW, Avalanche
- Matthew Tkachuk, RW, Panthers
- Patrice Bergeron, C, Bruins
- Timo Meier, LW/RW, Sharks
- Mitch Marner, RW, Maple Leafs
- David Pastrnak, RW, Bruins
- Elias Lindholm, C, Flames
- Victor Hedman, D, Lightning
- John Tavares, C, Maple Leafs
- Evander Kane, LW, Oilers
- Jake Guentzel, LW, Penguins
- Kyle Connor, LW, Jets
- Sebastian Aho, C, Hurricanes
- Mika Zibanejad, C, Rangers
- Andrei Svechnikov, LW, Hurricanes
- Brayden Point, C, Lightning
- Filip Forsberg, LW, Predators
- Johnny Gaudreau, LW, Blue Jackets
- Dylan Larkin, C, Red Wings
- Jack Eichel, C, Golden Knights
- Patrick Kane, RW, Blackhawks
- Aaron Ekblad, D, Panthers
- Alex DeBrincat, LW, Senators
- Kris Letang, D, Penguins
- Chris Kreider, LW, Rangers
- Elias Pettersson, C/LW, Canucks
- Vladimir Tarasenko, RW, Blues
- Artemi Panarin, LW, Rangers
- Kevin Fiala, LW/RW, Kings
- Anze Kopitar, C, Kings
- Nazem Kadri, C, Flames
- Roope Hintz, C, Stars
- Joe Pavelski, C/RW, Stars
- Bo Horvat, C, Canucks
- Pierre-Luc Dubois, C, Jets
- Evgeni Malkin, C, Penguins
- Jason Robertson, LW, Stars
- Josh Norris, C, Senators
- Mark Scheifele, C, Jets
- Jack Hughes, C, Devils
- Jacob Trouba, D, Rangers
- Joel Eriksson Ek, C, Wild
- Drake Batherson, RW, Senators
- Darnell Nurse, D, Oilers
- Tomas Hertl, C, Sharks
- Charlie McAvoy, D, Bruins
- Claude Giroux, C/RW, Senators
- Ryan Hartman, C, Wild
- Adam Fox, D, Rangers
- Matt Duchene, RW, Predators
- Brad Marchand, LW, Bruins*
- John Carlson, D, Capitals
- William Nylander, RW, Maple Leafs
- Patrik Laine, LW/RW, Blue Jackets
- Vincent Trocheck, C, Rangers
- Morgan Rielly, D, Maple Leafs
- Nikolaj Ehlers, LW/RW, Jets
- Pavel Buchnevich, LW/RW, Blues
- Moritz Seider, D, Red Wings
- Sam Reinhart, C/RW, Panthers
- MacKenzie Weegar, D, Flames
- Tage Thompson, C, Sabres
- Sam Bennett, C, Panthers
- Drew Doughty, D, Kings
- Evgeny Kuznetsov, C, Capitals
- Devon Toews, D, Avalanche
- Robert Thomas, C, Blues
- Nick Suzuki, C, Canadiens
- Nico Hischier, C, Devils
- Bryan Rust, RW, Penguins
- Adrian Kempe, LW/RW, Kings
- Valeri Nichushkin, LW/RW, Avalanche
- Blake Wheeler, RW, Jets
- Mats Zuccarello, RW, Wild
- Logan Couture, C, Sharks
- Thomas Chabot, D, Senators
- Sean Couturier, C, Flyers*
- Alex Pietrangelo, D, Golden Knighs
- Brock Nelson, C, Islanders
- Dougie Hamilton, D, Devils
- Noah Dobson, D, Islanders
- Tim Stuetzle, C/LW, Senators
- Brent Burns, D, Hurricanes
- Zach Werenski, D, Blue Jackets
- David Perron, RW, Red Wings
- Brayden Schenn, C/LW, Blues
- Mason Marchment, LW/RW, Stars
- Tyler Bertuzzi, LW/RW, Red Wings
- Seth Jones, D, Blackhawks
- Jordan Kyrou, LW/RW, Blues
- Jesper Bratt, RW, Devils
- Jonathan Marchessault, LW/RW, Golden Knights
- Teuvo Teravainen, LW/RW, Hurricanes
- Jamie Benn, C/LW, Stars
- Ryan Johansen, C, Predators
- Ryan O’Reilly, C, Blues
- Brock Boeser, RW, Canucks
- Ryan Nugent-Hopkins, C/LW, Oilers
- Matt Boldy, LW/RW, Wild
- Alex Tuch, RW, Sabres
- Viktor Arvidsson, LW/RW, Kings
- Phillip Danault, C, Kings
- Trevor Zegras, C, Ducks
- Rasmus Dahlin, D, Sabres
- Jeff Skinner, LW, Sabres
- Quinn Hughes, D, Canucks
- Mark Stone, RW, Golden Knights
- Mikael Granlund, C, Predators
- Tyler Seguin, C/RW, Stars
- Torey Krug, D, Blues
- Matt Barzal, C, Islanders
- Clayton Keller, LW/RW, Coyotes
- Miro Heiskanen, D, Stars
- Taylor Hall, LW, Bruins
- Oliver Bjorkstrand, RW, Kraken
- Michael Bunting, LW, Maple Leafs
- Radko Gudas, D, Panthers
- Jared McCann, C/LW, Kraken
- Troy Terry, RW, Ducks
- Tanner Jeannot, RW, Predators
- Justin Faulk, D, Blues
- Marcus Foligno, LW/RW, Wild
- Ryan Strome, C, Ducks
- Anthony Cirelli, C/LW, Lightning*
- Jean-Gabriel Pageau, C, Islanders
- Chandler Stephenson, C/RW, Golden Knights
- Jeff Carter, C, Penguins
- Jordan Staal, C, Hurricanes
- Shea Theodore, D, Golden Knights
- Tony DeAngelo, D, Flyers
- Andrew Copp, C/RW, Red Wings
- Zach Hyman, LW/RW, Oilers
- Travis Konecny, RW, Flyers
- Matt Dumba, D, Wild
- Mikhail Sergachev, D, Lightning
- Cole Caufield, RW, Canadiens
- Jakob Chychrun, D, Coyotes
- Tom Wilson, RW, Capitals*
- Andrew Mangiapane, LW/RW, Flames
- Rickard Rakell, LW/RW, Penguins
- Kevin Hayes, C, Flyers
- Boone Jenner, C, Blue Jackets
- Josh Morrissey, D, Jets
- Anton Lundell, C, Panthers
- Tyler Toffoli, LW/RW, Flames
- Lawson Crouse, LW/RW, Coyotes
- Rasmus Andersson, D, Flames
- Mikael Backlund, C, Flames
- Neal Pionk, D, Jets
- Reilly Smith, RW, Golden Knights
- Dylan Strome, C/RW, Capitals
- Evan Bouchard, D, Oilers
- Matty Beniers, C, Kraken
- Conor Garland, LW/RW, Canucks
- Andre Burakovsky, LW/RW, Kraken
- Alex Killorn, LW/RW, Lightning
- Noah Hanifin, D, Flames
- Cam Atkinson, RW, Flyers
- Anders Lee, LW, Islanders
- Jakub Vrana, LW, Red Wings
- Yanni Gourde, C, Kraken
- Jordan Greenway, LW, Wild
- Nick Schmaltz, C/RW, Coyotes
- Ilya Mikheyev, LW/RW, Canucks
- Luke Schenn, D, Canucks
- Ryan Pulock, D, Islanders
- Carter Verhaeghe, LW, Panthers
- Jared Spurgeon, D, Wild
- Lucas Raymond, RW, Red Wings
- Ondrej Palat, LW, Devils
- Anthony Mantha, LW/RW, Capitals
- Mason McTavish, LW, Ducks
- Jesse Puljujarvi, RW, Oilers
- Shayne Gostisbehere, D, Coyotes
- Evan Rodrigues, LW/RW, Avalanche
- Bowen Byram, D, Avalanche
- Ivan Provorov, D, Flyers
- John Klingberg, D, Ducks
- William Karlsson, C, Golden Knights
- Erik Haula, C/LW, Devils
- T.J. Oshie, C/RW, Capitals
- Jeff Petry, D, Penguins
- Erik Karlsson, D, Sharks
- Nicolas Roy, C/RW, Golden Knights
Notable omissions: Max Pacioretty, LW, Hurricanes*; Blake Coleman, LW/RW, Flames; Jaden Schwartz, LW, Kraken; Jonathan Toews, C, Blackhawks; Tyson Barrie, D, Oilers; Colton Parayko, D, Blues; Jakub Voracek, LW/RW, Blue Jackets; Rasmus Ristolainen, D, Flyers
